Peanut butter is a staple food item in about 95% of US households. And it’s easy to see why: It’s versatile, nutritious, and tasty. If peanuts are not your favorite (or you’re allergic), you’ve got more options than ever before, including almond butter, hazelnut butter, cashew butter, sunflower seed butter, sesame seed butter (also called tahini), and soy nut butter. There are even some mixed nut butters available. A good old PB&J will never go out of style. But if you’re looking for other ways to use nut and seed butters, we’ve got lots of ideas to share.
How Do Nut and Seed Butters Compare to Each Other Nutritionally?
Nut and seed butters share some basic characteristics. In general, per tablespoon they all have around 90-100 calories, 8-9g of fat, 2.5-4g protein, and 1-2g fiber. (Macadamia nut butter is different, it’s higher in calories and fat and lower in protein.) They tend to be good or excellent sources of minerals, including copper, magnesium, manganese, iron, selenium, and phosphorus. Nut and seed butters also tend to contain mostly monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats. But some—like Brazil nut and hazelnut butter—have substantial amounts of saturated fat.
Many nut and seed butters earn Guiding Stars. Some don’t earn any Stars, usually because of added ingredients like sugar. You can read ingredient labels and look for products with just a few, or select Guiding Stars-earning butters to help you find better choices quickly. And don’t forget to check out which brands earn Stars (and why some don’t) ahead of time using the Food Finder tool.
Got Allergies?
Where nut and seed butters generally differ widely is allergenicity. Peanuts and tree nuts are major allergens. And sesame became the ninth major allergen in 2023, so tahini isn’t a safe swap for everyone. Sunflower seed butter is a popular non-nut butter among people with allergies. But be sure to always read ingredient labels and consult your doctor or dietitian about which products are appropriate for you.
Our Top Ways to Take Nut and Seed Butters Beyond Bread
Don’t let spreading bread be the only way you enjoy nut and seed butters. There are so many other things you can do with them!
Sauces, Dressings, and Dips
Whipping up a little sauce, dressing, or dip usually takes just a few ingredients and a few minutes. An immersion blender is a handy tool for this job. But a blender or just a whisk and a strong arm can get it done too. You can go either savory or sweet here. Drizzle tahini dressing over salads or roasted vegetables. Serve chicken skewers alongside a delicious peanut butter dipping sauce—also great as a kid-friendly dip for fruit and veggies. Stir sunflower seed butter into yogurt for a creamy dip for celery sticks. Blend almond or cashew butter into hummus. Create a quick almond butter or peanut butter sauce for noodles, stir-fries and grain bowls (our Thai-Style Peanut Noodles recipe gives simple inspo for this).
Baking and Homemade Snacks
Nut and seed butters add flavor and richness, and can help bind ingredients together when making granola bars and energy bites. Our Guiding Stars recipes include many snacks with nut and seed butters (Oatmeal Peanut Butter Bumps are a perennial favorite). These Cashew-Date Snack Bars call for peanut butter and cashews, but you can choose other nut or seed butters if you prefer. For a super easy snack or breakfast on-the-go, simply spread your favorite nut butter on a whole-grain waffle and top with fruit. Or do the same with a whole-grain tortilla and make a quick roll-up like these simple Peanut Butter & Fruit Rolls.
Elevate Everyday Dishes
These ideas don’t take a new recipe or much effort, but they can take your usual meals new places flavor-wise. Try these simple ways to add nut and seed butters to what you are already eating:
- Swirl your favorite nut butter into oatmeal, overnight oats, or chia pudding.
- Drizzle tahini into lentil soup before serving, or combine it with lemon to top roasted veggies.
- Add cashew butter to vegetable stews to thicken and enrich it, or add it to coconut-based curries. (If you want a soup recipe using peanut butter, check out our Moroccan-Inspired Tomato Soup.)
- Stir tahini into a vinaigrette dressing and make it creamy instantly, without mayo.
